Navigating Job Offers: Is Requesting a “Go-Away” Salary a Sound Decision?
In the dynamic career landscape, opportunities can arise from the most unexpected places, leaving professionals pondering the best course of action. Recently, I found myself in such a predicament and it sparked some serious contemplation.
Six months ago, I made the decision to transition from Company A, where I earned a salary of £30,000, to Company B, which offered a significantly more lucrative £50,000. Given the substantial salary increase, the choice seemed straightforward at the time.
Fast forward to the present, Company A has reached out to me, offering a chance to return, this time for a more senior role following another employee’s departure. While I enjoyed my time at Company A, the proposition of returning so soon has left me torn. I’ve not only made a professional commitment to Company B, but I’ve also physically relocated closer to my new workplace, establishing new routines and settling into a new environment.
This brings me to a crucial question: Would it be inappropriate or detrimental to propose a significantly higher salary—let’s say over £70,000—as a condition for my return? This strategy could either result in a beneficial outcome or might serve as a deterrent, effectively allowing me to maintain my current position without burning bridges.
The stakes are high as a move back might portray me as indecisive or unreliable in the eyes of the industry, potentially impacting future career opportunities. However, if Company A accepts this hypothetical “go-away” salary, the financial upside could be difficult to overlook.
It’s a complex decision weighing professional reputation against financial incentives, and I wonder how others have navigated similar scenarios. Is aiming for a “go-away” salary a viable strategy, or should one prioritize long-term career prospects over immediate financial gains?
2 Comments
Navigating career decisions, especially when past employers re-enter the picture, can be challenging. It’s great that you’re considering various aspects before making a decision. Let’s unpack your situation and explore some strategies that could work well for you.
1. Assessing Your Value and Market Demand:
Given that you have a rare skill set, your expertise is a significant asset. In the ever-evolving job market, having niche skills can provide you with a leverage point. Before you proceed with any discussions, it’s crucial to assess the current market rate for your skills and experience. Reviewing industry salary reports or consulting with a specialized recruiter can give you a realistic figure of what your expertise is worth in today’s market.
2. Evaluating Career and Personal Goals:
Consider what you value most in your career at the moment. Is it monetary compensation, job satisfaction, career progression, work-life balance, or something else? Since you enjoyed working at Company A and are currently at Company B, weigh these factors in the context of both roles. Additionally, think about your personal circumstances, such as your recent relocation, and how this might impact your decision-making.
3. Exploring Negotiation and Communication Tactics:
If you’re contemplating a return to Company A, consider having an open and transparent discussion with them. Express your gratitude for their interest and inquire about their long-term vision for the role and possibilities for professional growth. If you eventually decide to propose a higher salary, ensure it’s grounded in the market analysis you conducted. It’s important to frame the salary as a reflection of your skills, the senior position they’re offering, and market dynamics rather than as a deterrent.
4. Considering Your Reputation and Industry Relations:
Reputation is vital in any industry. Making frequent moves can be a potential red flag for future employers, so it’s crucial to handle this situation delicately. When communicating with Company A, maintain professionalism, regardless of the outcome. If you decide not to return, phrase your decision in a way that emphasizes your current commitments and how they align with your career trajectory. This approach can help preserve your professional relationships.
5. Making a Decision with Confidence:
Ultimately, you should feel comfortable and confident in whatever decision you make. If Company A values you enough to meet a premium salary expectation, and it aligns with your current ambitions and life circumstances, it might be a worthwhile consideration. Conversely, if guaranteeing your current role’s stability at Company B feels more aligned with your goals, communicating
This is a fascinating topic that many professionals can relate to, and it raises some important considerations. While the prospect of requesting a “go-away” salary can certainly feel enticing, it’s essential to reflect on the broader implications of such a move.
Firstly, it’s crucial to evaluate the reasons for your initial departure from Company A and whether those factors have changed. If your past role had issues that could resurface, returning might not lead to the satisfaction you’re seeking, even with a higher salary.
Moreover, consider how such a request might affect your long-term career trajectory. Industry reputation can be fragile, and while the salary offer could be sweetened, returning to a previous employer can sometimes lead to perceptions of instability or a lack of commitment. It might be beneficial to frame your conversation around how you can contribute to Company A at a higher level rather than focusing solely on compensation.
If you do decide to negotiate a higher salary, make sure you’re backed by research and are ready to discuss your value and the unique skills you bring from Company B. This approach maintains professionalism and keeps the focus on your contributions rather than creating a potentially uncomfortable negotiation stance.
Ultimately, weigh the importance of financial gains against your long-term professional happiness and career advancement. Networking with trusted peers or mentors—who can provide their own insights based on experience—can also be incredibly valuable as you navigate this complex decision.