Rethinking Recruitment: Why Limiting Job Ads to Small Populations Could be a Missed Opportunity
As I was browsing LinkedIn recently, I stumbled upon something that left me scratching my head. A job listing for a Business Development Manager with a beverage brand caught my eye, primarily because it seemed to be targeted exclusively at a surprisingly small audience—about 20,000 people residing in one of the UK’s most commuter-friendly postcodes.
The role involves managing partnerships with retail clients within the EC postcode, which aligns well with those deeply embedded in the local business scene. However, the restriction seems puzzling considering the vast number of potential candidates living within a mere 30-minute commute, not to mention those just a brisk 10-minute bike ride away, like myself.
It raises the question: Why would a recruiter limit such an opportunity to such a small demographic? With millions of qualified candidates readily willing to commute and bring their expertise to the table, this narrow focus might mean missing out on top talent who could drive the brand’s growth to new heights.
In an era where flexibility and inclusivity are key hiring principles, expanding the application pool beyond the immediate vicinity could ensure a diverse range of skills and experiences. Broadening the scope not only benefits eager job-seekers but also enhances the potential for creative and dynamic business solutions within the company.
It’s worth considering whether the rationale behind such a constrained recruitment strategy truly serves the company’s best interests. After all, great talent often transcends postcode boundaries.
1 Comment
bdadmin
It’s understandable to be perplexed by such a narrowly targeted job advertisement, especially for a role like Business Development Manager, which typically benefits from a broader pool of applicants. There could be several reasons behind this seemingly counterintuitive decision, and understanding these might provide some clarity.
Firstly, the company might be looking for candidates with specific local knowledge or connections within the EC postcode. For roles like Business Development, where relationship-building is crucial, having a candidate familiar with the area’s unique market dynamics, trends, or key players could be highly advantageous. A locally based candidate might have established networks or insights that someone from outside the area may not possess. Thus, restricting the pool could be a deliberate strategy to ensure that candidates possess intimate local expertise that can drive business growth effectively.
Secondly, logistical considerations might be at play. Despite the area being commuter-friendly, the company could be aiming to minimize potential time lost to commuting challenges, something they believe could be a factor despite robust transport links. By hiring someone situated within or very near the EC postcode, they might perceive a lower risk of absenteeism, lateness, or burnout associated with longer commutes, which could affect performance and retention.
Additionally, there could be strategic reasons linked to company culture or remote working policies. Post-pandemic, some organizations still prefer having their teams close by to facilitate in-person collaboration and maintain a certain organizational culture. Even if remote work is part of the norm, having the option for the quick, face-to-face meetings a local candidate can provide might be seen as beneficial.
Practically speaking, if you are interested in the role and feel you’re a strong candidate, I would suggest applying regardless of the restriction if you think your skills and proximity (10 minutes by bike is indeed negligible) strongly align with the job requirements. Highlight your proximity to the EC postcode in your application, emphasizing your understanding of and familiarity with the area. If the recruiters are fixed on their criteria due to one of the aforementioned reasons, your application might still prompt them to reconsider the benefits of a slightly wider catchment area.
In the meantime, it might be useful to reach out directly to the recruiter or the company’s HR department. Express your interest in the role and clarify their reasoning for the geographic restriction. This approach not only shows initiative but could also open up a valuable dialogue, potentially leading to an opportunity.